Skip to content
Still Well After 40
Menu

Nobody Quits on the Bad Day. They Quit on the Flat One.

I trained four days a week and the scale went up anyway. I wrote this one for me first. You can read along.

By Adam Greene · · 6 min read

Still Well After 40 card on dark green reading: Still in the Middle. It doesn't get a vote this time.

Still in the Middle is my running account of getting healthier after 40, written while I’m still in it. This is entry three. Entry one is how I got here. Entry two is about the men’s group I was in.

Friday morning, October 16, the scale read 279.2. Three days earlier it said 275. Four pounds back in three days.

I’d been in the gym four days that week and put miles on the track and the treadmill. Food was good, mostly. There was one bowl of Blue Bell Classic Pecan Pie ice cream. I wasn’t sorry until I stepped on the scale. Honestly, I’m still not. It was delicious.

I stood on the scale longer than I needed to. Then I went and sat on the edge of the bed and thought about the couch.

I spent most of my forties on that couch. I got to 338.9 pounds on it. I’ve lost about 63 since, and I know how easy it would be to go back, because the couch never asks anything of you.

Mostly I’m just tired. The alarm goes off and my knees vote no before I’m even awake. And there’s a voice in the back of my head, real calm, real reasonable, asking what the point is.

I know that voice. It talked me out of a lot of years. It doesn’t get a vote this time.

The flat part

The early months are easier. Your pants get loose. Somebody you haven’t seen in a while asks if you’ve lost weight, and for a while you’d show up to the gym in a snowstorm.

Then it stops. You keep doing the work, the scale sits there or creeps up a little, and nobody says anything because there’s nothing to see.

That’s where I’ve quit before. More times than I can count. I’d start a diet, drop 10 or 20 pounds, and hit a wall. One week with no real loss. Then a second week. Then screw it: pizza, Doritos, and a weekend-long binge of old movies and video games.

Looking back, most of those walls weren’t walls. They were excuses. I told myself my body just wanted to stay fat, because that gave me permission to go back to the thing that always comforted me, which was food.

It was never a bad day that did it. A bad day makes me mad, and mad will get me to the gym. It was always some dull week where nothing happened and I decided the whole thing wasn’t worth it.

This time has been different. I came down pretty steadily for eight to ten months. Then I hit a real wall, about a month where nothing moved. I took a couple of small breaks and wasn’t as strict for a while, but I didn’t throw out the changes I’d made. I didn’t gain much. I just held. Then I started hitting the gym harder, added more cardio on top of the weights, and the scale started dropping fast again.

So four pounds in three days shouldn’t scare me. It did anyway. I looked at that number and saw the old pattern starting up, and for a minute I felt the fear that this was it.

The excuses I know by heart

I’ve used every one of these, so I recognize them when they come back around.

“I’m too old for this.” I’m 50. That’s the reason I can’t keep waiting.

“It’s not working.” It worked for 63 pounds. One bad week doesn’t erase that.

“I’ll get back on it Monday.” I said that for years. Monday never once showed up on its own.

“Maybe this just isn’t for me.” That’s the dangerous one, because it sounds like wisdom. I believed it at 338.9. I was wrong then, and I’d be wrong now.

Who I’m doing it for

I don’t need to look like a guy in a magazine. I need to be around.

Here’s the vulnerable part. I’m addicted to seeing my family proud of me for the changes I’ve made and the ones I’m still making. I like being proud of myself, too. I like feeling better. I like knowing I’m not making choices that betray my body anymore. For most of my life it felt like my body and I were on opposite sides. Now we’re on the same team, playing for the same goal.

There isn’t one thing I want to keep being able to do with my family. I want to do everything with them. And when the time comes, I want to do everything with their families too: grandkids, and great-grandkids if God and time allow it. I want to accomplish every task I was created with the potential to accomplish. I want the world to be a better place, a much better place, for my having lived in it.

My wife carried more than her share during the heavy years. I think about that on the mornings I don’t want to go. My daughters and my son are watching, too, whether they say so or not. If I fold on a flat week, that’s the lesson they get from me. If I keep going, they get a different one.

And my friends. They were my friends when I was on the couch, and they’re my friends now. If something I write here ever helps one of them, or anybody else, that’s the best thing it could do.

What I’m doing this week

This is my plan. Steal whatever helps.

Show up, even if it’s short. Some days this week I’ll do half a workout. Half still counts.

Keep the streak. I put a check mark on the calendar every day I train. Personal records can wait.

Watch the trend, and quit staring at the morning number. When you push your training up, your muscles get tiny tears, and your body holds fluid around them while it repairs. Cleveland Clinic says that usually clears in a day or so. Your muscles also stock more glycogen, the fuel they burn, and glycogen holds water. That can add 1 to 3 pounds, and Cleveland Clinic says the effect is short-lived, gone in a few weeks to a month.1 On top of all that, a normal day can swing 2 to 3 pounds either way, mostly fluid.2

So a heavier week while I’m training this hard is often water and fatigue. Often, not always. That’s why I write the number down and watch where it goes.2 I weigh on a couple of set days a week, same time, same clothes. One week tells me almost nothing. Two months tells me plenty. If the line is still climbing in a month, I’ll take a hard look at what I’m eating.

Sleep. The workout is the signal. Recovery is when your body answers it. I’m going to bed on time every night this week, with the phone in the other room. If sleep is your weak spot too, read Recovery and sleep in midlife before you add another mile.

Back off without disappearing. This much tired might mean my training has gotten ahead of my recovery. Hospital for Special Surgery lists warning signs of overtraining, and a few of them sound a lot like my week: fatigue that hangs on, heavy legs, lousy sleep, and lifts or pace that stall out. Their answer is rest.3 A deload week means you ease off the intensity or the volume for a week and keep moving.4 I might take one. Backing off for a week on purpose is fine. Disappearing for a month and calling it rest is how I got to 338.9.

And if the tired doesn’t lift after a real week of rest, or something else feels off, I’m calling my doctor. Tough guys get bloodwork too.

Why I wrote this

I wrote this one for me. Sitting on the edge of that bed, I realized something bigger than four pounds has changed in me over the last year and three months. I’m not going back to the old way of living. I’m going after the best life I can have, period. If it takes a little longer, or I have to work a little harder, that won’t stop me.

That’s when I decided to write this down.

If you’re in a flat stretch too and wondering whether any of this works, it does. It worked for 63 pounds. It’s slow, some weeks it’s ugly, and this is one of the ugly ones.

I’m tired and a little discouraged. And I Will Not Go Quietly.

Don’t go quietly.

This is my personal story and opinion, not medical advice. Check with your doctor before starting or changing an exercise program.

Sources

  1. 1.Gaining Weight After Working Out? Here's Why. Cleveland Clinic.
  2. 2.Why Does My Weight Fluctuate So Much? Cleveland Clinic.
  3. 3.Overtraining: What It Is, Symptoms, and Recovery. Hospital for Special Surgery (HSS).
  4. 4.Why You Should Have a Deload Week. Cleveland Clinic.

Links checked October 17, 2026. Figures are quoted from the sources above; associations in observational studies don't prove cause and effect.

Keep reading

The Still Well letter

Plain-English notes on strength, energy, recovery, and staying capable after 40. No hype, no spam. The list launches soon — until then, reach us at [email protected].

Signup isn't open yet. We'll turn this on when the email list is ready.